Since entering graduate school in the early 1960’s Dr. Beck has been interested in the effects of electron correlation on atomic properties. The nonrelativistic Hartree-Fock and relativistic Dirac-Fock methods are widely used independent particle models which take into account the average Coulomb repulsion between one electron and all other electrons. The difference between the results of these methods and the exact solution is correlation, the mixing of electronic configurations. For medium to high Z (atomic number) atoms, relativistic effects must be included simultaneously with correlation, but no general, publicly available, independent particle computer program existed until the mid 1970’s. Until then Dr. Beck was constrained to look only at low Z atoms. The Beck research group currently uses the relativistic configuration interaction (RCI) methodology using a suite of computer codes that Dr. Beck has developed over the last three decades.

The following time line tracks the developments in this methodology as well as changes in personnel of the Beck research group. For more details about the atomic properties calculated by the group, see the research interests page.


A general Dirac-Fock Computer Code, written by J. P. Desclaux, becomes publicly available. It provides the radial algorithms necessary for the correlation code.
D. R. Beck, while in Greece, begins work on angular algorithms needed to do relativistic correlation calculations. The presence of open d or f shell electrons, which is fairly typical in medium to high Z atoms, presents substantial computational challenges, which we are continuing to overcome, even at present.
D. R. Beck (now at MTU) and C. A. Nicolaides calculate relativistic and correlation effects separately for inner electron binding energies of medium Z atoms.
G. Aspromallis (a grad student/postdoc of C. A. Nicolaides and D. R. Beck), C. A. Nicolaides, and D. R. Beck, compute the lifetime of a long-lived Be state, which decays relativistically. Correlation and relativistic effects are still treated separately. The lifetime prediction is later confirmed experimentally.
D. R. Beck publishes the methodology needed for a combined relativistic and correlation treatment, and applies it to bound states in Zn. The formalism used is that of Grant. At this stage, only energy differences for bound states can be computed.
D. R. Beck and Z. Cai (D. R. Beck’s first MTU Atomic Physics student) publish electron affinities (EA) for Mn, Cr, Fe, Co, and Ni using the new methodology.
D. R. Beck and Z. Cai extend the methodology to calculate electric dipole (E1) transition probabilities for bound states and apply it to transitions in Tl II.
Z. Cai, D. R. Beck, and W. F. Perger extend the methodology to resonances, and apply it to Hg I. The key step is the creation of a radial continuum function algorithm, implemented by W. F. Perger (EE faculty, MTU).
D. R. Beck and D. Datta (the second atomic physics graduate student) extend the methodology to calculate hyperfine structure (HFS) and apply it to Ag I, Sc II, Y II, Ti I, Ti II, Zr II, Nb II, and La II. The reason for the discrepancy between theory and experiment for HFS of certain states is found and accounted for. Lifetimes for two Nb II states were also obtained. During this period, a procedure (REDUCE) is inserted into the codes which allows reductions of the number of basis functions by factors from 3 to 100, allowing small (~350) energy matrices to be used. This is an essential step in permitting calculations to be done on complicated states.
A modified version of an existing (Weber) large scale matrix diagonalizer is inserted into the code by K. D. Dinov (the third atomic physics graduate student) and D. R. Beck. This allows energy matrices as large as 7000 to be treated. K. D. Dinov also creates a program which simplifies construction of the input data files enormously, and yields error-free data. Previously, these multi-thousand line files took much preparation time.
K. D. Dinov, D. Datta and D. R. Beck publish EA’s for the lanthanide elements Ce and Pr and the actinides Th, U, and Pa in a series of papers. At this time, none of these have been measured, and the calculations are the first using p and d attachments for these atoms.
S. M. O’Malley (4th atomic physics graduate student) and D. R. Beck apply the methodology to Cs II and Ba III (HFS) and Tb, Sb, Sn, and La (EA’s). The results for Sb, Sn, and La are in good agreement with contemporaneous measurements. The Sn work is our first systematic inclusion of second order effects (triple and quadruple excitations) which are important for greater accuracy generally, and also in more complicated systems. This work includes the first application of our magnetic dipole (M1) and electric quadrupole (E2) transition probability algorithms.
E. N. Avgoustoglou (Ph.D. Notre Dame) joins the group as a postdoc, and using relativistic many body perturbation theory (RMBPT) predicts EA’s for Ca, Sr, Ba, and Yb. His Yb work is the first predicting (later confirmed) the non-existence of this negative ion. RMBPT calculations are also done for resonance transitions in Ne, Ar, Kr, and Xe; these serve as the theoretical standard.
The methodology is applied by D. R. Beck to reduce theoretical experimental discrepancies in energy differences for highly ionized members of the 3d4 isoelectronic sequence.
D. R. Beck extends the methodology to allow computation of Landé g values, and publishes results (including lifetimes) for Cs II.
P. L. Norquist (5th atomic physics student) and D. R. Beck apply the methodology to compute EA’s for Ru and Os. These predictions are later found to be in good agreement with experiment. In order to do the calculations, the REDUCE algorithm is upgraded to handle more complicated cases.
S. M. O’Malley computes EA’s for Ce and Lu in anticipation of a measurement, and E1 transition probabilities for Fe V in order to test some newly published results. The purchase of new memory (1 GB), allows the matrix size to be increased to 20k, and still reside in memory. The increased size is first used for Fe V. Shortly thereafter, P. L. Norquist and D. R. Beck complete a calculation for Ta II E1 oscillator strengths using the new code. A modification is made to the transition probability code allowing all optical transitions for the same initial and final state J’s to be done at once, which speeds up the Ta II calculations by a factor of 70.
M. G. Tews (6th atomic physics graduate student), W. F. Perger, D. R. Beck, and P. L. Norquist calculate the lifetime of a very long-lived Ba state, which decays by relativistic autoionization. W. F. Perger’s radial continuum program is modified by M. G. Tews and W. F. Perger, and D. R. Beck and P. L. Norquist begin to thoroughly automate and extend the programs used by Z. Cai for Hg I resonances. When completed, the program will be a fully relativistic generalization of the code used by G. Aspromallis for the Be lifetimes.
S. M. O’Malley and D. R. Beck finish calculations for E1 transitions in Tc I. The configurations are so complicated, that REDUCE must be heavily modified. Application to Fe II is made in 2004 by D. R. Beck.
D. E. Woon and D. R. Beck speculate that atomic anions possessing several bound states may form anion hydrides with more than one bound state. This is indeed the case for SiH and GeH.
D. R. Beck and others extend the work to the more complicated rare earth ions, specifically energy differences of 4f11 Er IV which is associated with an important lasing transition within a GaN host. Later (2006) calculations are done by D. R. Beck for 4f7 Gd IV which is important in PbF2:Gd scintillators. Accuracies of ~1000 cm−1 can be achieved.
L. Pan (7th atomic physics student) and D. R. Beck complete calculations on isoelectronic Zr III, Nb IV, and Mo V, repositioning the 5s2 Nb IV level, and obtaining the first ab initio f values. In Mo V, 4p54d3 levels are found to be relatively low-lying. Their treatment is made difficult because more core-valence (core-core) correlation must be included. The simpler Mo VI species, for which there are some observations (sometimes conflicting) is also examined.
Several of the Rare Earth EA’s measured by J. S. Thompson and V. T. Davis are larger than our theoretical predictions. For Tm and Eu long lived excited states may be what is observed (neutral atoms left in excited states). For Ce, the discrepancy seems to be associated with the ~26 bound Ce states which complicate interpretation of the observations, as indicated by the photoionization cross sections calculated by S. M. O’Malley and D. R. Beck.
L. Pan and D. R. Beck calculate the 1s ionization potential (IP) and excitation energies in Krn+ and Brn+ (n=0, 1, 2). These are needed for synchrotron studies. Relaxation, correlation, QED effects, and continuum shift effects must be included. Theory and experiment agree to ~1 eV for the 1s IP of Kr I. The remaining discrepancy may arise in part from missing QED effects.
S. M. O’Malley, L. Pan, and D. R. Beck make substantial improvements in obtaining photodetachment cross sections of rare earth anions with the addition of the following: (1) extensive shell scripts and codes that prepare data and manage runs, (2) extensive reduction of 4fn couplings with little loss with the subsequent large reduction in basis size (and number of determinants in some cases), (3) better correlated final state functions including the effect of resonances and partial inclusion of interchannel correlation using the Fano and Mies theory, and (4) a systematic attempt to identify, a priori, which are the important photodetachment channels. Initial application is to the Nd and Hf anions.
S. M. O’Malley develops a generalized angular momentum addition program, allowing efficient and systematic preparation of input data with JLS term restrictions on subgroups of electrons. S. M. O’Malley and D. R. Beck initially use the methodology to restrict the 4f4 and 4f3 subgroups of Nd and Nd each to a single term (5I and 4I, respectively). Basis sizes are limited by this procedure nearly on par with REDUCE without its complications of second order correlation losses due to the reference selection issues.
S. M. O’Malley expands and automates the angular momentum addition program and its methodology, allowing for the selection of secondary LS terms and decreasing data preparation time considerably. S. M. O’Malley and D. R. Beck apply the methodology to the entire lanthanide row, including 6p attachments to all 4fn6s2 and 4fm5d6s2 ground states (mn−1) and 6s attachments to open-s excited thresholds. These are the first ab initio EA calculations for Pm through Er.




Work on energetic solids was supported by the Office of Naval Research and the Department of Energy.
David Lucas, MTU, PhD (Clusters of nitromethane)
David E. Woon, MTU, MS (Vk centers in LiF)


Work on the constituents of natural gas was funded by the Gas Research Institute and involved calculation of potential energy surfaces.
David E. Woon, MTU, PhD (H2S dimers through 3rd order)
Peitao Zeng, MTU, MS (CH4-H2S and CH4-H2O)
David H. Gay, MTU, PhD (CH4 and H2O dimers through 4th order)
Houfeng Dai, MTU, MS (Second Virial coefficients for CH4 and H2O)


Work on properties of atoms and ions was funded by the National Science Foundation and the Department of Energy.
George Aspromallis, Greece, PhD
Ziyong Cai, MTU, MS
Ziyong Cai, MTU, PhD
Debasis Datta, MTU, PhD
Konstantin D. Dinov, MTU, PhD
Steven M. O’Malley, MTU, PhD
Michael G. Tews, MTU, MS
Peggy L. Norquist, MTU, PhD
Lin Pan, MTU, PhD
Eric Domeier, MTU, MS

e-mail Dr. Beck
back to the Beck group’s main page
back to the MTU Physics page

The Beck research group gratefully acknowledges current funding by the National Science Foundation (1981 to present) and prior funding from the Department of Energy (1992 to 2007). Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed on this website are those of the Beck research group and do not necessarily reflect the views of NSF or DOE.